Skip to main content

Psychological Security in the Workplace - "The Fearless Organisation" by Amy C. Edmondson




I am reading the book "The Fearless Organisation" by Amy C. Edmondson, of Harvard Business School.

A lot of her points really hit home for me.  I have been privileged  to  inhabit several work environments that have very open to feedback and willing to hear divergent opinions and ideas.  We enjoyed healthy disagreement,  that helped us make positive changes at work.  

As I have progressed through my career, I've been rewarded with increasing responsibility and with it a broader influence, and the opportunity to experience different environments with differing degrees of psychological safety.  

In the unhealthy environments, I have observed pockets of subversive behaviour, dishonesty,  fear and a general malaise in the team atmosphere.  Much of this is predicated on those who turn small mistakes into catastrophe by spreading exaggerated and false statements about potential risks, blaming and shaming or creating cliques.  There are also those who lead with subversion, blindside colleagues with alternative agendas, and lob unsubstantiated arguments and accusations into our midst all with the intention of creating confusion and chaos.  

Sounds "Trumpian" doesn't it?  

Intellectually it's quite interesting and fascinating to see this.  However experiencing this is really quite disappointing and disheartening.  This kind of behaviour definitely, slows productivity and growth.

Here is a clip to Edmundson talking about the fearless organisation:




 Edmondson, who has spent her life studying psychological safety in the workplace points to many factors at play that create unsafe environments to work in:

  1. Leadership that only welcomes good news
  2. Falling for an "illusion of success" / setting impossible goals or standards
  3. Failing to speak up - dangerous silence
  4. Excessive confidence in authority
  5. Dismissing Warnings
  6. Going Along to Get Along
  7. Promoted and Protected
Challenges to moving toward a truly fearless organisation include our natural tendency to avoid "losing face".  Lets "face" it no one likes to be humiliated, and many people are afraid to be wrong. But what is wrong with taking a risk and putting ideas out there?  NOTHING. 

Some of the examples and recommendations that made sense to me is:
  1. Candid feedback is not a "gotcha" . I definitely work in a "gotcha" environment right now.
  2. Criticism needs to be constructive - not destructive 
  3. Asking questions when you disagree --> this is really a helpful segue into conversation.  It will generally work with reasonable thinking people.  Some people who contribute to psychologically unsafe workplaces are unaware of their negative impacts.
    1. good questions generate curiosity
    2. stimulate reflection and reflective conversation
    3. highlight assumptions and biases
    4. invite problem solving and collaboration

I am going to try and pay attention to these principles, continue what I do well, and work on those I am not strong at.  I'd highly recommend reading this book - it's relevant to everyone and applicable to a wide array of work environments; I think you could even employ some of this outside of work.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Why I think Tim Caulfield Should Rethink His Top 5 List of Things to Do For Your Health

Professor Timothy Caulfield gave a very entertaining lecture this evening as part of the Edmonton Community Foundation's ECL Lecture Series.  In fact he has done a lot of research and published extensively in both the scientific and lay press about how popular culture is shaping our approach to health, and our attitudes towards science.  Interesting reading. The rise of pseudoscience, propagated by celebrities like Gwyneth Paltrow, Jenny McCarthy, and Dr. Oz just to name a few, has led to our society believing and trying all sorts of weird and wonderful things in the name of beauty and greater health.   As a physician, I am often struggling to debunk myths and provide my patients with solid medical advice and references that they can access to answer their questions. Unlike Dr. Caulfied, I have not done a lot of rigorous research in this area; so hats off to him for doing this and in such an interesting area.  As a consumer, mom, professional, and human being I am interested

Why The COVID19 Pandemic could be very good for Diabetes Care

I have wanted to develop "Just-in-time" care for patients with diabetes via the idea of a virtual clinic.  What this means to me is that the right patient is connected with the right diabetes team at the right time. Our current paradigm is to have pre-scheduled clinic visits - a nice, tidy, orderly progression of patients coming to see the team for advice.  There are several problems with this model - it's not really the best use of limited resources.  Patient selection is random in that patients who come happen to be the ones who were referred, but this does not necessarily equate to those who need to be seen the most.  Conceivably, if each member of the team (RN, RD, MD) spends time with the patient, up to 3 or more hours are dedicated to serving one patient.  It's just not efficient and it's not really patient centred care when the patient has to take time away from work and the costs also include transportation, parking, childcare etc.  For many patients

Being Human in a World Dominated by Politics, Power and Greed

I cried when I saw the image of Abdullah Kurdi, holding the body of his 3-year-old drowned son Alan, just before he was buried in a public funeral in Kobani. http://www.cbc.ca/news/world/drowned-syrian-boys-mother-buried-in-kobani-1.3215349 It's an image that I won't forget.  His is just one of hundreds of thousands of stories that highlight how our world deals with humans in an unkind and unfair way.  I'm not an expert in politics, economics, religion, or law - but I can say that we all live on this earth and I'm pretty sure that we could share it more equitably. The thing about this story that made me cry the most - was the fact that Abdullah and his deceased family were flown to a city near Turkey's border with Syria and the enscorted to Kobani by police.  Why did I cry?  I couldn't help but think about how much that must have cost, and how many children like Alan could have been fed, clothed, housed, or relocated to safety for the price of this expen